
Consistency Breeds Trust. Inconsistency Closes People Off
Originally published at https://benlobaugh.medium.com/consistency-breeds-trust-inconsistency-closes-people-off-a9c8b12930a9
A young leader, let’s call him Charles, recently approached me, struggling with his boss. Charles is a bright and promising individual who constantly seeks to improve himself within the company. He’s a team player and a strong advocate for his people. However, he worked under a leader whose inconsistent behavior made his job increasingly challenging.
This leader often stated he had an open-door policy and encouraged team members to discuss any issues. But when Charles brought up problems, his boss would get frustrated and demand solutions instead of focusing on collaborative problem-solving. On one occasion, Charles’s boss asked him for information about a new topic Charles had limited knowledge of. Instead of using this as an opportunity for shared learning, the boss publicly berated Charles in front of the leadership team. Understandably, Charles felt flustered and humiliated.
Over time, Charles realized his boss’s behavior followed a troubling pattern. Despite claiming to be approachable, his boss’s unpredictable reactions made Charles feel unsafe bringing up ideas or concerns. Charles no longer trusted his boss, and instead of being an advocate for his team, he started avoiding discussions, meetings, and initiatives. He feared his boss’s erratic responses, which could range from enthusiasm to anger.
When Charles sought my advice, I shared a key principle of effective leadership: Good leaders are consistent leaders. Consistency builds trust. People need to know they can count on you to respond reliably, regardless of the circumstances.
Reaction vs. Response
There are two ways to handle information: reacting and responding. A reaction is instinctual — like ducking when a baseball is flying at your head. A response, on the other hand, is a deliberate and thoughtful action — like catching the ball to prevent injury to yourself or others.
As a leader, your responses should be measured and consistent. This doesn’t mean you suppress emotion but that you take a moment to assess and choose the best course of action. By doing so, you create a safe environment where your team feels valued and supported.
Why Consistency Matters
Inconsistent leadership erodes trust. If your team doesn’t know how you’ll react, they’ll hesitate to share ideas, raise concerns, or go the extra mile. Over time, this lack of trust results in disengagement. Employees might show up, do the bare minimum, and leave without investing passion or energy into their work.
Your people are your greatest asset. Without them, you wouldn’t have a company. It’s easy to get caught up in the importance of products or customers, but remember: those things only exist because of your team’s efforts.
Rebuilding Trust
If you haven’t been a consistent leader, it’s not too late to change. Rebuilding trust is hard work, but it’s worth the effort. Start by committing to consistent, positive responses in every situation. Whether an employee brings up a problem, shares critical feedback, or raises a challenging issue, respond with respect and thoughtfulness.
Be prepared for tests along the way. There will be moments when you’re tempted to revert to old habits. Resist the urge. Even a single lapse can undo progress. However, if you persevere, you’ll foster a team that trusts you deeply, feels safe in their work environment, and is willing to go above and beyond for shared goals.
The Payoff
A consistent leader builds a team that is loyal, motivated, and resilient. I’ve experienced this firsthand. On challenging projects where others might have given up, my teams pushed through because they trusted me and knew I would support them. Conversely, I’ve seen teams fall apart under inconsistent leaders, sometimes leading to a company’s collapse.
Take Action
Work hard to become the consistent leader your team needs. It’s not about being perfect but about being dependable and fair. If this feels overwhelming, know that resources are available, and I amhere to help.
You CAN be the leader others admire. You CAN build a team that excels. You CAN foster loyalty and dedication that leads to extraordinary results.